A New Look for Seahorse Chocolate, With Its Craft Intact
Emily Pappo, a former coffee buyer and climate researcher, takes over Bend, Oregon’s Seahorse Chocolate, pairing a new look and origin lineup with the steady hand of founding maker RC Gartrell.
Emily Pappo was a customer before she was the owner. A year after buying the Oregon-based bean-to-bar chocolate maker, she's given it a new look, new origins, and an active conservation agenda. The person making the chocolate hasn’t changed.

Seahorse Chocolate has always made very high-quality chocolate from carefully sourced ingredients. Since 2017, the small workshop in Central Oregon has been turning single-origin cacao beans into bars that, in my view, could have reached far more people than they did. Under its founders, it was a local business at heart, focused on its home community rather than a national or international market.
It seems that those goals have now changed. In September 2025, Pappo and her family acquired the business. A year later, the company looks really different. The packaging is new, the website has been rebuilt, the lineup includes new origins, the team is far more engaging online, and the brand has become noticeably more visible on the chocolate scene. This year, they won two bronze medals at the International Chocolate Awards and participated in the Northwest Chocolate Festival in Seattle.

I knew Seahorse long before the sale, collaborating with its original founders and keeping tabs on their work. What kept me coming back was their purist approach. After so many years of tasting chocolate, I am drawn mostly to two-ingredient dark chocolate bars made with just cacao and sugar, or cacao alone. Cacao beans already contain natural cocoa butter—roughly half the bean is made of cocoa butter—so adding extra simply "dilutes" the flavor profile. In my experience, leaving it out often delivers a deeper, richer, more concentrated tasting experience and a longer aftertaste.
Seahorse’s dark selection has consistently delivered what I look for: a firm, pronounced snap; a dense, creamy texture; and a slow, even melt that lets each batch's flavor profile develop and linger on the palate.
When I saw that the company had changed hands and began noticing new faces on social media, I reached out to the new team. They sent me samples, and I met Pappo in person at the 2026 Northwest Chocolate Festival, where I was attending as a media partner and judge for the Best in Show competition. Afterward, I interviewed her about the transition, her background, and what comes next.
From the Coffee Bar to Climate Research
Pappo was already a loyal customer long before she bought the company. Living in Bend with her husband and son, she considered Seahorse “our favorite local bean-to-bar chocolate maker.” Before taking over, her career moved between specialty coffee and environmental science.
She started her coffee career at a specialty shop in New York in 2008, while studying environmental science at New York University. What hooked her immediately was “the nuances of crafting an incredible cup, and the environmental and social impacts of the supply chain.”
She followed that supply chain back toward its agricultural roots. A move to Hawai‘i took her to a coffee farm and eventually to a position in Portland, Maine, as a commercial coffee roaster and green coffee buyer until 2019. Sourcing regularly placed her on farms throughout the tropics, where the practical realities of a changing climate became unmistakable: “Spending time on farms with producers around the world got me curious about the ways in which climate change was impacting production.”
That curiosity led to graduate study: first a master’s degree in agronomy, then a Ph.D. in interdisciplinary ecology focusing on climate resilience in agroecosystems. Her research investigated how climate variability affects crop yields, sensory quality, and profitability for smallholder coffee farmers across Latin America. After completing her doctorate in 2023, she continued as a postdoctoral fellow with the Smithsonian’s National Zoo and Conservation Biology Institute and the Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute, working with the Smithsonian Bird Friendly Coffee and Cocoa program on agroforestry systems that support both biodiversity and farmer livelihoods.
Yet research alone left a commercial gap. As she saw it, the most direct intervention was still market-driven: “While I love doing research, I kept finding myself drawn back to the business side of the equation. Ultimately, what better way is there to support producers doing the hard work of sustainable production than buying more of their product, at better prices?”
She began looking for a way back into the commercial sector where her background in agronomy and sourcing could create tangible economic demand for sustainable agriculture. That was when Seahorse was listed for sale.
Buying Instead of Building
Building a new chocolate brand from the ground up was an option, but stepping into an established workshop made far more sense. As she explained when we spoke, the foundation was already solid: “I was so grateful for the opportunity to take the helm at an established and respected brand like Seahorse Chocolate.” Since 2017, the original team had focused on “honing their chocolate-making craft and growing a supportive and passionate community of customers. So, I was incredibly lucky to step into a business that already made a great product, and that skill and commitment to quality is baked into the foundations of Seahorse.”
Meeting the founders confirmed that alignment: “I was so excited to find that so much of our values around sustainability and quality and our backgrounds aligned.” Just as crucially, the person making the chocolate did not change. RC Gartrell, one of Seahorse’s co-founders, stayed on as lead chocolate maker.
“RC is still leading our chocolate-making operations, so we have been able to guarantee that commitment to quality through the ownership transition.” With production continuing in experienced hands, she has been free to focus on expanding supply-chain impact, refreshing the brand identity, and growing the audience.

The handover proved collaborative from the start, with the founders being “so gracious to me and open and willing to share their hard-earned knowledge and expertise at every step.” Taking that foundation forward is now her responsibility: “Of course, now it’s up to me to figure out how to use all that knowledge and experience to inform what comes next, how we grow our sustainability impact and get our chocolate into more folks’ hands.”
Two Coffee Roasters, One Chocolate Company
The connection between Pappo and Gartrell is more than a shared interest in small business. Both came to bean-to-bar chocolate from specialty coffee. Coffee and cacao potential is determined on the farm and in the post-harvest process, and both rely on careful roasting to coax out origin character without "scorching" delicate aromatics.
That shared roasting background gave them an immediate shorthand: “It is certainly an area where we connected early on, and we share that language and sensibility when it comes to roasting and quality evaluation. Of course, RC is still roasting and making our chocolate, so that approach has carried forward.”
Her incredible breadth of experience across coffee—on the farm, in roasting production, and in academic research—gave her a head start in understanding fine-flavor cacao. As a certified Q Arabica Grader since 2017—a credential requiring rigorous sensory training—she found the transition natural: “A lot of that experience transitions really nicely to fine cacao and bean-to-bar chocolate making, and it has been incredibly fun to learn more about tasting and evaluating cocoa and chocolate over this past year.”

One specialty coffee ritual made the trip directly into the Bend workshop: a weekly team tasting modeled on traditional coffee cupping, where they evaluate recent batches side by side. “We call it our ‘cupping’ as a nod to our shared coffee roots! So, while I’m always learning something new, it’s been exciting to see how our team’s coffee background can continue to improve our roasting and chocolate making.”
When it comes to the selection itself, that continuity remains non-negotiable: “There are some things that we deliberately did not change, and will not ever change: specifically, our commitment to quality and our approach to responsible sourcing, careful drum roasting, and our chocolate-making process all stayed exactly the same through the ownership transition.” Her message to longtime customers is clear: “If you loved Seahorse Chocolate in 2024 pre-transition, you’ll still love it in 2026, because what is in the wrapper hasn’t changed!”

What Changed: The Look, The Team, and Bird-Friendly Cacao
While the chocolate-making stayed steady, almost everything around it expanded. The most visible shift arrived in February 2026 with a complete rebrand. Over her first year, Pappo worked with a design team to introduce a new logo, redesigned packaging, and a fresh website.
The goal was clarity on the retail shelf: “We wanted our packaging to help customers connect with our bars and differentiate between origins on the shelf.” Seahorse moved to vibrant, color-coded pouches inspired by the canopies and foliage of tropical cacao agroforests. The new logo features a hybrid of a horse and a seahorse—what she calls “a nod to both our origins as a company and the terrestrial origins of cocoa.”
In a retail market where the range from the same maker often looks indistinguishable from several feet away, the color-coding is a smart choice. It lets shoppers quickly navigate origins while signaling the brand’s renewed personality.
Longtime buyers welcomed the change: “This was a big change, but we’ve seen a big positive response to our new look, and we are grateful for the customers who have been willing to explore this new direction with us!”
To support that visibility, a small team came together. Emery joined as Brand & Community Manager, steering direct-to-consumer sales and an engaging social media presence, while Zac came on as Operations & Partnerships Manager, overseeing wholesale accounts and fulfillment. Seahorse also stepped onto the national circuit, exhibiting at the Northwest Chocolate Festival, the Specialty Food Association’s Summer Fancy Food Show, and the Good Food Awards.
For Emily, that broader engagement is central to the craft: “I see chocolate making as a creative endeavor, and there is a lot of space for creativity in the bean-to-bar market. Each maker I’ve met is doing something unique and interesting with quality, sourcing, marketing, you name it.”
Her research background has also steered new sourcing partnerships. Seahorse became the first craft chocolate maker licensed under the Smithsonian Bird Friendly cocoa program. Long established in specialty coffee, the certification requires farms to be 100% organic, deforestation-free, and cultivated beneath diverse native shade canopies that preserve bird habitat and forest biodiversity. Seahorse sources Bird Friendly cacao from the Zorzal estate in the Dominican Republic, pairing it with Audubon-verified bird-friendly maple sugar for a Maine Maple Sugar bar, and lemon-infused flake sea salt for a Flaky Sea Salt bar.
She also tapped her specialty coffee network to bring in new cacao origins, partnering with green coffee and cacao importers Osito Coffee & Cacao. That collaboration yielded a standout single-origin bar from La Cueva del Oso in Huila, Colombia, which promptly took a bronze medal at the 2026 International Chocolate Awards USA alongside the Zorzal 70%.

Where Seahorse Sits
For chocolate enthusiasts who know the American craft landscape, the easiest way to place Seahorse is between Dandelion Chocolate and Dick Taylor Craft Chocolate.
In terms of texture and mouthfeel, their tasting experience is much closer to Dick Taylor. While Dandelion’s two-ingredient bars often offer a slightly drier tactile quality on the palate, Seahorse’s chocolate carries a denser, creamier texture and an unhurried, rich melt. Aromatically, their range sits between Dandelion’s bright, roast-forward clarity and Dick Taylor’s warm, rounded, deep-toned profiles. If you appreciate those makers' integrity and focus, you will immediately understand and enjoy what Seahorse is doing.

Seahorse Chocolate Bars
Tasting through the current lineup confirms that the company’s quality standards remain firmly intact. The two-ingredient dark bars show the clean snap, dense texture, warm mouthfeel, and slow melt that have defined them for years.

La Cueva del Oso, Huila, Colombia 70%: The newest addition to the single-origin range, sourced through Osito, is my favorite. The profile opens on a refined molasses foundation with smoky, earthy depth and subtle mineral undertones. Layers of sweet dried fruit follow—dark raisins, dates, and candied citrus peel—before giving way to an unexpected top note of dried wild mint. That mint introduces an herbaceous lift with mild peppery sparks and gentle citrus bitterness, resting on warm wood and earth. The finish leaves a clean, lingering cooling sensation that makes it exceptionally memorable.
Camino Verde, Durán, Ecuador 70%: It opens with rich aromas of raw almond butter, toasted cinnamon pastry, and the gooey center of a chocolate brownie. A heavy note of dark buckwheat honey steps in—robust, bold, and slightly gamey on the nose—brightened by a sweet, floral, and nutty hint of rose of Sharon. The mid-palate melt is deep and comforting. My one "reservation" is the finish, which turns slightly dry and astringent, recalling the tactile grip and flavor of roasted peanut skin. Astringency is a puckering, drying sensation on the tongue rather than an off-flavor, and here it cuts short an otherwise expressive aftertaste.
Left of the Dial 78% Blend: This blend brings together cacao from the Dominican Republic and Belize into an impeccably smooth bar. It leads with classic dessert notes of fudge brownie, rich dark cacao, and unrefined brown sugar, balanced by a tangy pop of pineapple and dried fruits like raisins and black figs. Secondary layers of cherry wood, cashew butter, and warm baking spices give it complexity. The finish softens into delicate honey and mild citrus, leaving an aftertaste reminiscent of a high-mountain Taiwanese oolong tea. At 78%, it showcases a remarkable sweetness and finesse—the ideal bar for someone who mistakenly believes high-percentage chocolate must taste bitter or "too strong."
Zorzal, Dominican Republic 70%: In my experience, dark chocolate made with Zorzal cacao can feel "polite" or "understated," often serving as a pleasant entry point for newcomers crossing over from commercial candy to craft chocolate. Seahorse’s version is far more engaging. While remaining approachable, sweet, and creamy, it offers substantial complexity: dark sweet cherry, toasted macadamia nuts, chewy toffee, dried figs, and warm chocolate lava cake, balanced by soft, integrated acidity.
Zorzal, Dominican Republic 100%: Made with pure cacao and zero added sugar, the 100% bar is exceptionally well balanced. Comparing it with their 70%, the profile shifts toward deep cacao, roasted nuts, and wood: dark brownie crust (baked dark, not burnt), dense flourless chocolate cake, hazelnut butter, cured sweet tobacco, cedar, and earthy soil, accented by hints of dried coconut, vanilla bean, and tart cherry compote. Because the cacao retains its full natural cocoa butter, it melts smoothly and feels fudgy rather than chalky or astringent.
Vegan Dark Coconut Milk: Formulated with coconut milk, coconut sugar, and additional cocoa butter, this bar offers a softer snap and a much faster, silkier melt than the two-ingredient dark bars. While I don’t typically seek out coconut milk chocolate, this bar is thoroughly enjoyable. Its standout feature is a bright orange creamsicle cake flavor, where candied citrus zest merges seamlessly with rich coconut and cacao for a sunny, tropical profile. It is the most openly indulgent bar in the collection—creamy and completely successful.

What Comes Next
Looking ahead, Emily frames the company’s future around three explicit priorities:
1) to make the best chocolate they have ever tasted,
2) to have a measurable impact on sustainable cocoa supply chains,
3) to be great partners for everyone we work with.
The second priority will receive significant focus over the coming year. Seahorse has committed to directing a percentage of its proceeds to scientific research on climate resilience and biodiversity conservation in cacao-growing landscapes. Currently, it fulfills that through 1% for the Planet, with a broader conservation funding initiative in development.
For longtime customers, the central message remains one of continuity: “I hope they notice that our commitment to quality and our approach to sourcing, roasting, and chocolate making has not only stayed consistent, but continued to improve!”

For the wider chocolate world, Seahorse was never a maker in need of fixing; under its founders, the chocolate was already exceptional, even if the business remained close to home. With Gartrell still at the roaster and Pappo bringing the company onto a larger stage, that craft remains intact—now matched by the ambition and visibility it has long deserved.




Comments